top of page
  • Writer Utopia

Oxygen Tanks vs Oxygen Concentrators: Which is Better?


tangki oksigen tangki oksigen hospital tangki oksigen mudah alih fungsi tangki oksigen


As all of us know, most people take breathing for granted. Unfortunately, it is a daily battel for patients who struggle with chronic respiratory diseases like COPD, pneumonia, or lung cancer, it can be a daily battle. For patients like them, the oxygen therapy is generally useful. As experts in our field, we do acknowledge that finding the ideal oxygen delivery system is essential in ensuring the greatest possible health outcome, regardless if you are a patient or a caretaker. That is where oxygen concentrators and oxygen tanks are useful. Which of these tools suits you better? Well, both of these tools mentioned in the title are intended to provide oxygen to those who are in need. We will examine the main distinctions between oxygen tanks and concentrators in this post to assist you in choosing the device that will best serve your unique needs. We got you covered, whether you are seeking for portability, affordability, or convenience.

oxygen tank portable oxygen tank medical oxygen tank diving oxygen tank

What Are Oxygen Tanks?

You may have heard of "oxygen tanks" if you or a loved one requires additional oxygen. But what are they specifically? Oxygen tanks are simply transportable tanks that are filled with compressed oxygen gas. Convenience is important when it comes to oxygen therapy. With this motto in their minds, there is an oxygen tank size that suits your demands, whether you like to spend your days indoors or outside. These tanks can survive the high pressure of compressed oxygen because they are normally composed of durable metal. Also, you will always be aware of how much oxygen you still have thanks to a built-in pressure gauge. We shall examine oxygen tanks in-depth further in this post to give you a better understanding of this crucial piece of respiratory therapy equipment.

Advantages of Oxygen Tanks

  • Portability and convenience: Convenience is important when it comes to oxygen therapy, and patients who need oxygen therapy while travelling might benefit greatly from oxygen tanks. They are not only simple to use and require no difficult setup or installation procedures, but your neighbourhood pharmacy or medical supply store likely has them in stock as well. Moreover, oxygen tanks are available in a range of sizes that are suitable for both home and travel use, giving those who require oxygen therapy a flexible option.

  • Consistent oxygen flow and durability: Consistent oxygen flow is essential for people with long-term respiratory illnesses. With the right care and maintenance, oxygen tanks can last a very long period and provide this reliability. Also, you do not need to bother about replacing them regularly due to their durability.

  • Backup option: Oxygen tanks are helpful not just for routine use, but they can also act as a trustworthy fallback when power outages or equipment malfunctions. They guarantee that patients can always receive the oxygen therapy they require even in distant locations with limited access to energy.

  • Affordability: When compared to alternative oxygen therapy choices, oxygen tanks are considered as inexpensive.

oxygen tank refill oxygen tank refill near me oxygen tank rental oxygen size e oxygen tank

Disadvantages of Oxygen Tanks

  • Frequent Refilling Required: One of the major drawbacks of oxygen tanks is that they require frequent refilling. The size of the tank and the patient's oxygen requirements determine how frequently the tank needs to be filled.

  • Costly Refilling: The cost of refilling the tanks can be high and accumulate over time.

  • Heavy and Difficult to Move: Another drawback of oxygen tanks is that they can be cumbersome and difficult to transport, which is troublesome for senior individuals.

oxygen concentrator portable oxygen concentrator yuwell oxygen concentrator oxygen concentrator malaysia

What Are Oxygen Concentrators?

As oxygen concentrators do not require refueling like tanks do, they are actually considered as a practical alternative to oxygen tanks. These electrical gadgets, which draw oxygen from the air around them, provide a longer-term, more cost-effective alternative. Since oxygen concentrators can continually administer oxygen, they are very helpful for patients who need a steady flow of oxygen. Also, they are simple to operate and have a switch or button on them. It's important to remember that oxygen concentrators need electricity to operate, therefore they might not be appropriate for usage in rural locations where power outages frequently occur.

Advantages of Oxygen Concentrators

  • Continuous flow of oxygen: Oxygen concentrators are perfect for patients who need oxygen therapy for a prolonged period of time since they deliver oxygen continuously. The reliable oxygen supply that oxygen concentrators provide can be helpful for patients with long-term respiratory disorders. Unlike oxygen tanks, which might have erratic supply, they offer a more constant flow of oxygen.

  • Utilization: Oxygen concentrators are simple to use and do not require any refilling. After being plugged in, they can draw oxygen from the air around the patient and distribute it to them via a nasal cannula or face mask. Oxygen cylinders are low maintenance because replacement or refilling are not required.

  • Cost-effectiveness: Compared to oxygen tanks, oxygen concentrators are more economical over the long term. Oxygen tanks must be often refilled, which can be expensive, particularly if the patient demands a high oxygen flow. Oxygen concentrators minimize the need for refills, which can ultimately savvy for the finance of both the patients and caregivers.

philips oxygen concentrator oxygen concentrator price angelbiss oxygen concentrator oxygen concentrator machine

Disadvantages of Oxygen Concentrators

  • Need a power source: Oxygen concentrators need a power source to function, which can be a big drawback if there is a power outage or if the patient needs to utilize it in a remote area with limited power options. This may limit their portability and application in particular circumstances.

  • Not that portable: Unlike oxygen tanks, oxygen concentrators cannot easily be transported around, which might be uncomfortable for patients who are constantly on the go.

  • High flow rate requirements: Patients who need high oxygen flow rates should not use oxygen concentrators as it only provides restricted amount of oxygen.

Which One Is Better?

The patient's unique needs and lifestyle will play a big role in the decision regarding oxygen tanks vs. oxygen concentrators. For patients who enjoy travelling or are frequently on the go, these tanks are the perfect option because they are lightweight and portable. However, individuals who require oxygen therapy for a prolonged period of time and do not frequently travel are best served by oxygen concentrators. These devices are lightweight and simple to move around the house. They also deliver a constant flow of oxygen, removing the need for frequent refills. In the end, choosing between oxygen tanks and oxygen concentrators should be discussed with a healthcare professional who can suggest the optimal choice depending on the patient's particular needs and lifestyle.

mesin oksigen mesin pernafasan oksigen mesin oksigen mudah alih mesin pernapasan oksigen


In conclusion, the best option for each patient ultimately determines whether to use oxygen tanks or concentrators. Both offer particular advantages and disadvantages, so it's crucial to weigh things like mobility, the length of oxygen therapy, and general lifestyle when selecting a choice. While oxygen tanks are helpful for people who need to stay active while receiving oxygen therapy, they can be difficult to transport and need more regular refilling. Conversely, oxygen concentrators provide a more practical, long-term solution for people who require oxygen therapy for a lengthy period of time, but they are less portable and could need a little more upkeep. If you are still confused about which choice is best for you after reading the article, we strictly advise you to see your physician or another appropriately certified healthcare professional beforehand. We believe that they can help you reach the optimal decision based on your preferences and health.

At OxiHome, we recognize the value of having access to oxygen therapy in the convenience of your own home. Because of this, we provide a dependable and practical solution in the form of a home oxygen concentrator machine. We have KKM & MDA approved machines that can be delivered to you in just 3 hours, whether you need to buy or rent. Our staff will even assist you in setting it up and giving you instructions so that you can easily begin your oxygen therapy. What are you waiting for? Please do contact us at OxiHome now for the best healthcare product, specially for you.


bottom of page